top of page

Exploring Transformation, Part II: Disorientation

Writer: Dr. Laura Boche
Dr. Laura Boche
3 minutes ago
3 min read

by Laura Boche, Senior Director of Postsecondary Strategy


As you may remember, I’m a fan of Brené Brown. In Part 1 of this series, I shared a key idea from the “Anatomy of Transformation” chapter in her book Strong Ground and what it means for higher education institutions. We looked at the importance of carefully breaking down old structures or ways of working – some that have become so entrenched, even sacrosanct, that we rarely question whether they still serve students or support institutional goals.


I now want to look at what comes next after that intentional, careful breaking. Once a few pieces of the china cabinet have been broken, transformation can be deeply disorienting. We’re not sure what is coming next, and being in that messy middle phase can be very uncomfortable.


For me, that is one of the hardest parts to push through. It’s like riding the Peloton: I’m 10 minutes into a 30-minute ride and already wishing I were at the one-minute cool-down. But as my instructors remind me, “Nothing changes if nothing changes.” The discomfort means something is changing. Transformation is supposed to feel uncomfortable!


Part of what makes transformation so disorienting is the set of paradoxes Brené presents in Strong Ground. It is both exciting and scary; clarifying and confusing; urgent, yet slow; empowering and exhausting. These paradoxes can be difficult to hold at the same time.


Another disorienting part of transformation is our own mental models. What if we are part of the system we are trying to transform? Brené describes this paradox as: Everything needs to change, except me. Think of several conversations you’ve had over the past month and how often you have heard any number of these phrases:

  • “Students aren’t prepared”

  • “Faculty won’t change”

  • “Advisors aren’t using the new retention tool”

  • “Departments won’t collaborate”

  • “Students don’t read their emails”

  • “Transfer institutions won’t accept our credits”


That last one may sound familiar from Part 1. When we looked more closely at why a community college marketing course wasn’t transferring, the barrier wasn’t an accreditation requirement. It was our assumption as the receiving institution about what counted as upper division. The problem we thought was “out there” was one we had built ourselves.


Sometimes the above statements are true, but institutions often diagnose problems as external. Meaningful transformation requires some institutional (and individual) self-examination. And that can be disorienting - it can mean changing what we believe about students, our responsibilities, and the systems we have built or inherited and come to know. We may actually be part of the problem. Transformation isn’t just about changing the system around us. We need to also examine how we participate in that system.


So then, how do we deal with these paradoxes and all of this disorientation?

For starters, we need capacity to live within these transformation paradoxes and survive the effort. Capacity is more than having enough people or enough budget to get the work done, as my colleagues Sarah Ancel and Dr. Vanessa Keadle write in Who Has the Time?. Transformation requires time and space for reflection, experimentation, relationship-building, learning, and simply trying. People need the capacity to step outside their day-to-day responsibilities to examine the system and imagine how it could work differently. Transformation requires capacity, not just capacity to do more, but the capacity to examine and think differently.


The more difficult question then becomes: What if the hardest part of becoming student-ready isn’t changing our programs? What if it is changing what we believe about students, our responsibilities, and the systems we have built or inherited? Answering this question requires vulnerability.


In Part 3, I’ll explore transformation fatigue – something many of us in higher education know too well – and share what I think transformation requires, using Brené’s framework.

 
 
 

Comments


© 2026 by Student-Ready Strategies.

bottom of page